Palavrão Tático

Podcast Policial de Los Angeles

669
Posts
Behind the Badge

Broken windows and the clock on a flagrante: why a California officer makes more arrests per shift — and the fight over the TCO in Brazil

If formalizing a small arrest takes an officer off the street for an entire shift, broken windows theory has no way to work. Eliel Teixeira and Edwin Wu do the math with delegado Maurício de Thomazi — and the TCO, Brazil's shortcut, becomes a dispute between police forces.

Episode 52 • Part 2 of 2
Janelas quebradas e o tempo do flagrante: por que o policial da California prende mais por turno — e a briga pelo TCO no Brasil
Illustration: a California police officer taking a report on the street

After discussing who is legally answerable for an arrest made in the act (the Brazilian flagrante), the conversation between Eliel Teixeira, Edwin Wu and Delegado Maurício de Thomazi of the São Paulo Civil Police moved down to the street: how long an arrest takes an officer off patrol, and what that does to one of the best-known ideas in modern policing, broken windows theory. For the hosts, who work in California, the Brazilian way of formalizing a flagrante carries an operational cost that goes beyond the legal debate.

Broken windows theory, in one sentence

The theory comes from a 1982 article in The Atlantic, "Broken Windows," by political scientist James Q. Wilson and criminologist George L. Kelling. The idea: a broken window that nobody fixes signals that nobody cares, and soon the other windows get broken too. Tolerated disorder and petty offenses open the way to more serious crime. The police response would be to act on the small stuff (vandalism, drug use in public, petty theft, disturbances) to contain criminal momentum in an area.

The theory became famous through the New York police in the 1990s, and drew criticism too: researchers question how much of the drop in crime it actually explains, and the model has been linked to mass stops in poor neighborhoods. But as a tool, it depends on a practical condition the hosts highlighted: the officer has to be able to arrest for the small crime without leaving the street for an entire shift.

The math that doesn't add up: one arrest per shift

The hosts did the math out loud. In Brazil, an arrest doesn't end when the suspect is handcuffed: the officer takes the prisoner to the station, waits for the delegado, gives a statement, waits for the report to be drawn up. In their perception, that is a "chá de cadeira" (a long wait on a chair) of 7, 9, even 10 hours, with the risk of seeing it all undone by someone who wasn't at the scene. If a minor crime takes 10 hours to formalize, they say, broken windows theory becomes impossible to apply: the officer who should be on the street spends the shift at the station.

On the American side, the reference point is different. One of the hosts tells what the most arrests he has ever made in a single 10-hour shift was, and says he couldn't repeat that in Brazil. In their view, in the United States an officer's productivity is measured precisely by what the system does to make arrests easier, including for the offenses "nobody wants to deal with."

How California handles minor crime: citation on the spot

Part of the American answer is simply not taking everyone to jail. In California, the rule for most misdemeanors is cite and release: the officer identifies the person, hands over a written notice to appear in court, and releases them on the spot (Penal Code 853.6). Arrest and transport to jail is reserved for the exceptions written into the law itself, such as when the person doesn't identify themselves, poses a danger to themselves or others, already has an open warrant, or is unlikely to show up.

The decision belongs to the officer, is recorded in the officer's report, and the case then goes to the prosecutor. With no intermediary between the street and the prosecution, a minor incident costs minutes of paperwork instead of hours at a station.

In Brazil, the shortcut has a name: TCO

The guest answered that this question "comes up all the time" in Brazil, and that it has a name: the Termo Circunstanciado de Ocorrência (TCO), a circumstantial incident report. Created by Law 9.099/1995, which set up the Special Criminal Courts, it is the simplified record for offenses of lesser offensive potential: misdemeanors and crimes with a maximum sentence of up to 2 years (article 61). Under article 69, the police authority draws up the report and sends the case to the court; if the offender commits to appearing, no arrest in the act is imposed and no bail is required. In practice, it is the Brazilian cousin of cite and release.

The dispute is over who may draw up the TCO. The law says "police authority," and delegados maintain that the expression refers to them. In several states, the military police claim the right to draw up the report right on the street, precisely to end the station bottleneck. The Supreme Federal Court (STF) has already given an important answer: in March 2022, in the judgment of ADI 5637, with Justice Edson Fachin as rapporteur, the full court unanimously upheld the Minas Gerais law (state Law 22.257/2016) that authorizes the Military Police and the Military Fire Department to draw up the TCO. The action, brought by the national association of delegados (Adepol), was rejected on the understanding that the TCO is not an investigative act and therefore is not exclusive to the judicial police.

Even so, practice varies from state to state. As the guest explained, some courts and states accept it more and others less, and where the military police have more political strength and more access to legislators and courts, they manage to organize themselves to draw up the report.

"The legislator's options"

The guest's underlying answer is the same one he gives in the classroom: these are the legislator's options. They carry the constitutional history of each place, the idea people have of each actor's role in the system, the experience courts have with the quality of each police force's work and, of course, political disputes. He calls this "a second layer of reality" on top of the written law.

And the hosts recognize the same logic on this side, because the United States is a federation in which each state writes its own criminal law. Crossing a state line can change what is a crime. The examples are real:

  • Oregon and Idaho, neighbors, which they called "different galaxies": Oregon legalized recreational marijuana in 2014 and, with Measure 110 (2020), went as far as decriminalizing possession of small amounts of any drug, a decision the legislature itself reversed in 2024 (HB 4002). In Idaho, marijuana remains prohibited even for medical use;
  • California and Arizona: since 2010 Arizona has allowed adults who can legally own a firearm to carry it concealed without a permit; in California, carrying requires a license (CCW) issued by the sheriff or the chief of police;
  • California itself changes: Proposition 47 (2014) turned theft of up to US$ 950 and simple possession of several drugs into misdemeanors, and Proposition 36, approved by voters in November 2024, toughened penalties again for repeat theft and some drug crimes.

That is why, they remind us, Palavrão Tático always talks about California and Los Angeles, since the first episode: there is no such thing as "the police of the United States." There is a common base, the Constitution and federal case law, but day to day the difference shows up even between neighboring states.

"To society, we are the police"

At the end, the guest made a point of making one thing clear. When it's said that the arrest goes through the delegado, that doesn't mean he is the boss of whoever made it: "I don't command the military police. I'm not their boss. I'm not better than them." He was simply placed in a legal position where he decides a lot. And he said he has "deep respect" for the work of the uniformed police: to society, "we are not two, three, four police forces. We are the police." The hosts answered in the same tone, with respect for Brazil's officers.

What the two think about it

Eliel Teixeira and Edwin Wu approach the subject from the viewpoint of people who measure their own work in arrests made and time on the street. Each one's conclusion about the Brazilian model, and the promise of a new collaboration with Criminocast, with charts and statistics, are in the episode.

Sources and verification

James Q. Wilson and George L. Kelling, "Broken Windows," The Atlantic, March 1982. Law 9.099/1995, arts. 61 and 69. Supremo Tribunal Federal (Brazil's Supreme Federal Court), ADI 5637 (rapporteur Justice Edson Fachin, judgment concluded in March 2022), on art. 191 of Minas Gerais Law 22.257/2016. California Penal Code § 853.6 (cite and release for misdemeanors). California Proposition 47 (2014) and Proposition 36 (2024). Oregon Measure 91 (2014), Measure 110 (2020) and House Bill 4002 (2024). Arizona, permitless concealed carry since 2010 (SB 1108). The time to formalize an arrest in the act and the number of arrests per shift are accounts and estimates from the hosts, not official statistics.


Who is speaking here: Eliel Teixeira and Edwin Wu are active-duty police officers in the Los Angeles area, California — Brazilian-born, American citizens, with long careers in law enforcement. In this episode, made in partnership with Criminocast, they close the four-part conversation with Maurício de Thomazi, a delegado of the Civil Police of the State of São Paulo, professor of criminology and criminal procedure, and host of Criminocast.

Note: what is described here about American policing applies to the rules of California — and, on several points, to each host's specific department. In other American states the rules change. What is described about Brazil applies to the Civil Police of São Paulo; each Brazilian police force has its own organic law and internal rules.

Watch this part of the episode:

Impact on street policing and Broken Windows Theory — starting at 23:46 · Palavrão Tático

Sources & editorial note

This article is a reference edition of episode 52 of Palavrão Tático and is subject to edits and editorial additions. For the full conversation, watch the episode. — Updated on 19/11/2026.

Keep reading
See all articles from this episode →


Loading...